Skip to main content

"Don't give them fish; teach them how to fish." Is that enough!


Every time we think about poverty, it's easy to see it from one perspective.


The most common worldview on poverty is "Don't give them fish; teach them how to fish."
As this is a great concept, we wrestle with how we need to think about it. Teaching them how to fish is a one-size-fits-all approach that works in one context but not all. It also needs to be fleshed out.

 We do not stand at one point globally and see the world differently; we actually see a different world. We see very differently when we see from the ground.

From where we recognize that:
a) There are very many systematic issues that contribute to what we call poverty. It's not just teaching them how to fish.

b) Fishing is done differently, and fishing is technologically supported.
c) We must listen actively to what the locals need and understand their unique perspectives.
d)Sometimes, there is no water available to fish. How do we bring water to them?

e)The community has to be part of the provided initiatives. They see way wider and broader than we see. We see fishing as a solution; sometimes, they think fishing isn't the solution. If they can't own the fishing, it remains a foreign concept.

d)When you teach them how to fish, and they get to fish, what do they do with the fish? You must think about systems that enable them to earn from their fishing. What markets are available? Who are the middlemen? Can you counter the middlemen, bring them to the market with an equal footing, and have them harvest the same benefits as the big shots. What if they bring their fish and compete with fish imported from other places that are way cheaper?

e) Let's say they get an income; how do they use it. Many will start to ask them to save!! So, how do you save when you haven't met your basic needs? Savings are set aside after one has met their basic needs. Not luxurious living but basic needs.


f) The issues affecting poverty are social, economic, environmental, and cultural dimensions. We must not be ignorant of the fact that their mindsets have to be ready to start fishing. Because it's not an easy task. 

A lot of people in poverty are not lazy; they work so hard, but systems are meant to keep them where they are. We must never equate poverty with laziness! No, we cannot. We must also not make people dependent on donor funding! No, we can't! We must think about the issues compassionately and find ways to engage.

In community development, seeing different worlds means appreciating the rich tapestry of human experience and understanding that solutions must be as diverse as the communities they serve. We must keep learning what it means for our society to deal with poverty.






Comments

Popular posts from this blog

                                                             This is My Story:Part 1  Early School Life through War!!! Once upon a time!! Haha. Well, the story of my life is a very long one. Today is the beginning of a series of "My Story" that I will keep writing when I have the opportunity. Its a reflection on my early school life.  My education journey began in the mid-1980s, a time when resources were scarce and instability was all too common. I remember writing on the ground because we had no books and no chalkboards for our teachers to use. When it rained, we huddled under a muddy shelter. Lunch was unheard of—during breaks, we would wander to nearby homes of our classmates, hoping to find jackfruit hanging from the trees.  My early memories of school are few, but what followed has left a lasting imprint.  As...
  This is My Story: Part 2   "My Life After the War" In the first part of "This is My Story," I shared glimpses of my early school life amid war. Today, I continue with the second chapter, “My Life After the War.”  When I look back, I realize that the effects of the war gave birth to a deep desire for something different. Join me as I further reflect.  When we returned from exile, we found our home destroyed—burned down and overgrown with bush.  For months, we were hosted by neighbors as my father worked to rebuild our lives. He managed to construct a small hut, but it was so tiny that only my parents could sleep inside. I had to find shelter with different neighbors for quite some time. Life was unbearably difficult.  Before the war, farming was not just our  source of income—it was how we fed ourselves and made any income.  The war disrupted everything, leaving us without food. Thankfully, some neighbors who hadn’t been chased away took pi...

This is my Story: Part 3 "Beyond the Village: A Journey for Knowledge, Wisdom and Understanding."

  In my last two episodes, I shared my childhood experiences first, during the war and after the war.   Today, I'll continue with the third episode, "Beyond the Village." With no high school near me, it was time to leave home and head to the nearest "big town," Jinja, Uganda. I had never imagined myself in a big town before. Jinja, an industrial hub, was unlike anything I had known. After enrolling in high school, I needed to find somewhere to stay. I ended up sharing a small hut with a classmate who had already rented it. I remember looking up at night and seeing the sky and moon through the roof. We had to sleep in shifts because there wasn't enough room for both of us simultaneously. As hard as life was in my village, I missed it. (This is one of my first ever pictures taken)!!!!!!  Back to the story!!  To make ends meet, I worked to pay for my school fees, accommodation, and food. I enrolled in a carpentry apprenticeship and worked with a carpenter, d...